Qiraat Africa
عربي  |  Fr
Advertisement
  • News
    • All
    • Climate Change
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Energy
    • Health
    • Migration
    • Mining
    • Politics
    • Security
    • Society
    • Sport
    Mozambique: Opposition leader Mondlane announces break in election protests

    Mozambique’s main opposition leader goes on trial over post-election unrest

    Eritrea wary of ‘war-mongering’ Ethiopia

    Ethiopia and Eritrea amass forces along border, heightening war fears, sources say

    Nigeria’s state-owned NNPC records $4.2 billion after-tax profit in 2025

    Nigeria’s central bank, NNPC sign deal to support forex inflows, energy funding

    South Africa arrests four men suspected of planning to fight for Russia

    South Africa police searches for motive behind deadly shootings

    Guinea plans regional gold refining hub as West African race intensifies

    Guinea’s miners stockpile gold after refinery rules halted exports, sources say

    Nigerian lawmakers mediate rift with Africa’s richest man

    Dangote Refinery to expand IPO by up to 30% to $2.1 billion, sources say

    Rwanda

    Five EU countries starting talks with Rwanda on deportation hub, Austria says

    Guinea says $1.9 billion deep-water port plan draws US, Chinese interest

    Guinea says $1.9 billion deep-water port plan draws US, Chinese interest

    AU grants $10.4m for Mpox emergency response

    Africa CDC says Ebola outbreak still out of control six months since it was declared

  • Analysis
    • All
    • Climate Change
    • Digital & Tech
    • Economy
    • Energy & Power
    • Health
    • Politics
    • Security
    • Society
    Free trade across Africa? Why policy must catch up with small-scale cross-border traders

    Free trade across Africa? Why policy must catch up with small-scale cross-border traders

    Hormuz block affected Africa in four places: what the continent must do to avoid future shocks

    Hormuz block affected Africa in four places: what the continent must do to avoid future shocks

    What is standing in the way of science’s ability to eradicate malaria? 3 areas where action can have an influence

    What is standing in the way of science’s ability to eradicate malaria? 3 areas where action can have an influence

    African Union summit clouded by Saudi-UAE rivalry in Horn of Africa

    Opportunities and Challenges of the AU’s Education in Emergencies Initiative

    Abiy Ahmed Tested: How the Tigray Alliance Is Reshaping Ethiopia’s Security—And What Comes Next

    Abiy Ahmed Tested: How the Tigray Alliance Is Reshaping Ethiopia’s Security—And What Comes Next

    UN report says Africa’s share of global trade stands at 3 percent

    AfCFTA: The Trade Rules Poised to Weave Africa’s Fragmented Textile Markets into One

    The global panel on inequality needs African evidence: here’s how it could work

    The global panel on inequality needs African evidence: here’s how it could work

    Why Africa needs a new credit agency

    Why Africa needs a new credit agency

    Japan signs deal with Namibia to explore for rare earth minerals

    Africa’s mineral strength is wasted if countries don’t work together – new report

  • Studies
    China could drive Africa’s renewable energy revolution, report says

    A study shows wind and solar projects in Kenya and South Africa don’t always benefit the communities that host them

    Angola’s lengthy war shaped the way farmers utilised fire—why it matters

    Angola’s lengthy war shaped the way farmers utilised fire—why it matters

    Schooling is the most severely affected by conflict when children are the target – Study

    Schooling is the most severely affected by conflict when children are the target – Study

    Pensions for Botswana’s elderly are expanding, but care services are lacking—study follows 20 years

    Pensions for Botswana’s elderly are expanding, but care services are lacking—study follows 20 years

    60 new cosmic structures have been discovered by South Africa’s MeerKAT telescope, which is mapping previously unseen gaps between galaxies

    60 new cosmic structures have been discovered by South Africa’s MeerKAT telescope, which is mapping previously unseen gaps between galaxies

    Benin government says armed forces foil coup attempt

    Coup contagion? A rash of African power grabs suggests copycats are taking note of others’ success

    One in three South Africans have never heard of AI: what this means for policy

    One in three South Africans have never heard of AI: what this means for policy

    Social Media as a Catalyst for the Spread of Dangerous Wealth Ritual Myths

    Social Media as a Catalyst for the Spread of Dangerous Wealth Ritual Myths

    Overcoming Education Barriers for Young Mothers in Sub-Saharan Africa

    Overcoming Education Barriers for Young Mothers in Sub-Saharan Africa

  • Infographics
  • Figures
    South Sudan’s presidency announces postponement of long-delayed election by two years

    South Sudan vote: UN warns political transition must hold beyond polling day

    Usman Dan Fodio (1754-1817): Teacher, philosopher, and revolutionary reformer

    Usman Dan Fodio (1754-1817): Teacher, philosopher, and revolutionary reformer

    Sokhna Magat Diop (1917–2003): Senegalese cleric

    Sokhna Magat Diop (1917–2003): Senegalese cleric

    Ahmad Baba al-Timbukti (1556-1627): Writer and scholar

    Ahmad Baba al-Timbukti (1556-1627): Writer and scholar

    Namibia: Anger over Dubai COP28 trip by president Geingob’s children

    Hage Geingob (1941–2024): Former President of Namibia

    Cape Verde president says governments must discuss colonial reparations

    José Maria Neves: President of Cape Verde

    Jorge Bom Jesus: Linguist and former Prime Minister of São Tomé and Príncipe

    Jorge Bom Jesus: Linguist and former Prime Minister of São Tomé and Príncipe

    Joseph Leabua Jonathan (1914-1987): Former Prime Minister of Lesotho

    Joseph Leabua Jonathan (1914-1987): Former Prime Minister of Lesotho

    Gambia’s president Barrow faces backlash over ‘death wish’ on archrival

    Adama Barrow: President of the Republic of The Gambia

  • History
    Kwanza Corridor-Cultural Landscape, Angola

    Kwanza Corridor-Cultural Landscape, Angola

    Gasumo, the southernmost source of the Nile, Burundi

    Gasumo, the southernmost source of the Nile, Burundi

    Loango ancient slavery harbour, the Republic of the Congo

    Loango ancient slavery harbour, the Republic of the Congo

    Archaeological site of Tchitundu-Hulu, Angola

    Archaeological site of Tchitundu-Hulu, Angola

    Manovo-Gounda St. Floris National Park, Central African Republic

    Manovo-Gounda St. Floris National Park, Central African Republic

    Lake Malawi (Lake Nyasa) National Park, Malawi

    Lake Malawi (Lake Nyasa) National Park, Malawi

    Fasil Ghebbi, Gondar Region, Ethiopia

    Fasil Ghebbi, Gondar Region, Ethiopia

    Bwindi Impenetrable National Park, Uganda

    Bwindi Impenetrable National Park, Uganda

    Fort Jesus, Mombasa, Kenya

    Fort Jesus, Mombasa, Kenya

  • Others
    • Culture / Literature
    • Interview
    • Opinion
  • Countries
    • Country profiles
    • Regions
      • Central Africa
      • East Africa
      • Southern Africa
      • West Africa
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • All
    • Climate Change
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Energy
    • Health
    • Migration
    • Mining
    • Politics
    • Security
    • Society
    • Sport
    Mozambique: Opposition leader Mondlane announces break in election protests

    Mozambique’s main opposition leader goes on trial over post-election unrest

    Eritrea wary of ‘war-mongering’ Ethiopia

    Ethiopia and Eritrea amass forces along border, heightening war fears, sources say

    Nigeria’s state-owned NNPC records $4.2 billion after-tax profit in 2025

    Nigeria’s central bank, NNPC sign deal to support forex inflows, energy funding

    South Africa arrests four men suspected of planning to fight for Russia

    South Africa police searches for motive behind deadly shootings

    Guinea plans regional gold refining hub as West African race intensifies

    Guinea’s miners stockpile gold after refinery rules halted exports, sources say

    Nigerian lawmakers mediate rift with Africa’s richest man

    Dangote Refinery to expand IPO by up to 30% to $2.1 billion, sources say

    Rwanda

    Five EU countries starting talks with Rwanda on deportation hub, Austria says

    Guinea says $1.9 billion deep-water port plan draws US, Chinese interest

    Guinea says $1.9 billion deep-water port plan draws US, Chinese interest

    AU grants $10.4m for Mpox emergency response

    Africa CDC says Ebola outbreak still out of control six months since it was declared

  • Analysis
    • All
    • Climate Change
    • Digital & Tech
    • Economy
    • Energy & Power
    • Health
    • Politics
    • Security
    • Society
    Free trade across Africa? Why policy must catch up with small-scale cross-border traders

    Free trade across Africa? Why policy must catch up with small-scale cross-border traders

    Hormuz block affected Africa in four places: what the continent must do to avoid future shocks

    Hormuz block affected Africa in four places: what the continent must do to avoid future shocks

    What is standing in the way of science’s ability to eradicate malaria? 3 areas where action can have an influence

    What is standing in the way of science’s ability to eradicate malaria? 3 areas where action can have an influence

    African Union summit clouded by Saudi-UAE rivalry in Horn of Africa

    Opportunities and Challenges of the AU’s Education in Emergencies Initiative

    Abiy Ahmed Tested: How the Tigray Alliance Is Reshaping Ethiopia’s Security—And What Comes Next

    Abiy Ahmed Tested: How the Tigray Alliance Is Reshaping Ethiopia’s Security—And What Comes Next

    UN report says Africa’s share of global trade stands at 3 percent

    AfCFTA: The Trade Rules Poised to Weave Africa’s Fragmented Textile Markets into One

    The global panel on inequality needs African evidence: here’s how it could work

    The global panel on inequality needs African evidence: here’s how it could work

    Why Africa needs a new credit agency

    Why Africa needs a new credit agency

    Japan signs deal with Namibia to explore for rare earth minerals

    Africa’s mineral strength is wasted if countries don’t work together – new report

  • Studies
    China could drive Africa’s renewable energy revolution, report says

    A study shows wind and solar projects in Kenya and South Africa don’t always benefit the communities that host them

    Angola’s lengthy war shaped the way farmers utilised fire—why it matters

    Angola’s lengthy war shaped the way farmers utilised fire—why it matters

    Schooling is the most severely affected by conflict when children are the target – Study

    Schooling is the most severely affected by conflict when children are the target – Study

    Pensions for Botswana’s elderly are expanding, but care services are lacking—study follows 20 years

    Pensions for Botswana’s elderly are expanding, but care services are lacking—study follows 20 years

    60 new cosmic structures have been discovered by South Africa’s MeerKAT telescope, which is mapping previously unseen gaps between galaxies

    60 new cosmic structures have been discovered by South Africa’s MeerKAT telescope, which is mapping previously unseen gaps between galaxies

    Benin government says armed forces foil coup attempt

    Coup contagion? A rash of African power grabs suggests copycats are taking note of others’ success

    One in three South Africans have never heard of AI: what this means for policy

    One in three South Africans have never heard of AI: what this means for policy

    Social Media as a Catalyst for the Spread of Dangerous Wealth Ritual Myths

    Social Media as a Catalyst for the Spread of Dangerous Wealth Ritual Myths

    Overcoming Education Barriers for Young Mothers in Sub-Saharan Africa

    Overcoming Education Barriers for Young Mothers in Sub-Saharan Africa

  • Infographics
  • Figures
    South Sudan’s presidency announces postponement of long-delayed election by two years

    South Sudan vote: UN warns political transition must hold beyond polling day

    Usman Dan Fodio (1754-1817): Teacher, philosopher, and revolutionary reformer

    Usman Dan Fodio (1754-1817): Teacher, philosopher, and revolutionary reformer

    Sokhna Magat Diop (1917–2003): Senegalese cleric

    Sokhna Magat Diop (1917–2003): Senegalese cleric

    Ahmad Baba al-Timbukti (1556-1627): Writer and scholar

    Ahmad Baba al-Timbukti (1556-1627): Writer and scholar

    Namibia: Anger over Dubai COP28 trip by president Geingob’s children

    Hage Geingob (1941–2024): Former President of Namibia

    Cape Verde president says governments must discuss colonial reparations

    José Maria Neves: President of Cape Verde

    Jorge Bom Jesus: Linguist and former Prime Minister of São Tomé and Príncipe

    Jorge Bom Jesus: Linguist and former Prime Minister of São Tomé and Príncipe

    Joseph Leabua Jonathan (1914-1987): Former Prime Minister of Lesotho

    Joseph Leabua Jonathan (1914-1987): Former Prime Minister of Lesotho

    Gambia’s president Barrow faces backlash over ‘death wish’ on archrival

    Adama Barrow: President of the Republic of The Gambia

  • History
    Kwanza Corridor-Cultural Landscape, Angola

    Kwanza Corridor-Cultural Landscape, Angola

    Gasumo, the southernmost source of the Nile, Burundi

    Gasumo, the southernmost source of the Nile, Burundi

    Loango ancient slavery harbour, the Republic of the Congo

    Loango ancient slavery harbour, the Republic of the Congo

    Archaeological site of Tchitundu-Hulu, Angola

    Archaeological site of Tchitundu-Hulu, Angola

    Manovo-Gounda St. Floris National Park, Central African Republic

    Manovo-Gounda St. Floris National Park, Central African Republic

    Lake Malawi (Lake Nyasa) National Park, Malawi

    Lake Malawi (Lake Nyasa) National Park, Malawi

    Fasil Ghebbi, Gondar Region, Ethiopia

    Fasil Ghebbi, Gondar Region, Ethiopia

    Bwindi Impenetrable National Park, Uganda

    Bwindi Impenetrable National Park, Uganda

    Fort Jesus, Mombasa, Kenya

    Fort Jesus, Mombasa, Kenya

  • Others
    • Culture / Literature
    • Interview
    • Opinion
  • Countries
    • Country profiles
    • Regions
      • Central Africa
      • East Africa
      • Southern Africa
      • West Africa
No Result
View All Result
Qiraat Africa
عربي  |  Fr
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

Kagame and the Rwandan Economic Miracle: Autocracy at its finest?

Chike D. Ibewuike by Chike D. Ibewuike
May 19, 2022
in Opinion, East Africa
Kagame and the Rwandan Economic Miracle: Autocracy at its finest?
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

It’s the mid-spring of 1994. Rwanda is in a haze of violence and bloodshed amidst Hutu-Tutsi clashes triggered by the death of President Juvenal Habyarimana, a Hutu. The international community merely spectates, and it only takes the efforts of the Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF) under the leadership of Paul Kagame to quell Hutu forces and enforce peace, albeit 100 days and 800,000 lives too late – a national hero is born.

Since then, in what has been described as an economic miracle, Kagame has led Rwanda across two decades of an average 8% GDP growth seeing the country go from a divisive and despairingly poor agrarian society to a progressively modern economy lifting one million people out of poverty in the process. In a continent with over 400 million people living in extreme poverty, it begs the question; how did Kagame and his RPF pull it off? But even more pertinently, shouldn’t his Rwandan miracle be used as a model for the rest of Africa? Well, the short answer to the second is no, and adequately answering the first would tell us why.

So, just how did they do it?

In the time after the genocide, the RPF’s first significant move was to outlaw former President Habyarimana’s party, the MRND, and rename the RPF’s military arm, the RPA (Rwandan Patriotic Army) making it the official national army, and by extension, Rwanda, a one-party state. Furthermore, just days after conflicts had ceased, the RPF began taking overall means of economic production and enterprise, from as low as the chair supply industry to as high up as government financing, eventually placing the party at the heart of Rwanda’s economy.

However, Kagame did not receive Rwanda’s reins immediately. He first served as vice-president and Minister of Defence under Pasteur Bizimungu manning the RPA — now the national army — to quell internal and external opposition until Bizimungu’s seemingly forced resignation due to a falling out with Kagame and the RPF in 2000. Kagame was appointed president shortly after permanently terminating the office of the vice-president. With executive and military power in his grasp, the RPF at the heart of the economy, and guaranteed political stability, he revitalized pre-genocide thriving industries like tea and coffee exports via party-owned enterprises rather than waiting for market stimulation.

Combined with careful management of state agricultural resources, the development of a parastatal to centrifugate and ease all concerns with starting a business to boost foreign direct investment, and a few constitutional amendments to maintain power while creating an impression of progressivism and political inclusion, and we have the fundamental pillars of the Rwandan Model – a one-party state that is led by an individual or organization with the power to stave off internal party resistance and external political opposition. And this leads us to the first reason why the Rwandan model cannot be replicated by most other African nations.

Different strokes for different folks

Rwanda is unique because there are barely any African countries with one dominant party. Apart from a few examples like Chad and Angola, almost no others have parties that can aspire to such lofty political motives. African states are mostly a mix of two or more dominant tribe-based political parties all jostling for power. Rwanda originally consisted of parties across its Hutu and Tutsi dominating tribes. Rwanda has only become a mono-political state due to the actions of Kagame and the RPF. Without the political security guaranteed, as in the case of Rwanda, funneling economic growth through one party would most likely lead to increased graft and corruption due to the termly nature of democratic power, and the short-sighted orientation of multi-party politics.

Regarding the practicality of the model, while most of the world’s poor live in Africa, they are based mainly in just five countries — Nigeria (79 million), the Democratic Republic of Congo (60 million), Tanzania (28 million), Ethiopia (26 million), and Madagascar (20 million) — all of which are multi-ethnic, multi-party system states diminishing the likelihood that the one-party state of Rwanda is an effective model to follow.

How long would the dream last?

Kagame’s nationalist heroics are not uncommon in Africa. Yoweri Museveni, Mu’ammar Al-Qadhdhāfī, Idi Amin, Robert Mugabe; African history is rife with ‘knightly nationalists’ who advocate dethroning the oppressors to the praise of citizens only later to become more oppressive than their predecessors.

In fact, from 1960 onwards, Africa has been home to 17 leaders who have ruled for at least 20 years, with 8 currently on the seat. This year marks Kagame’s 21st. In-depth research on African Power and Politics by David Booth best describes Kagame’s rule as developmental patrimonialism; a system where a leader manages the negative effects of patrimonialism with tight control while choosing economic champions, and managing inefficiencies. This only works because that leader’s intentions are more inclined toward national benefit than harm.

The question remains how long would the dream last and how likely is it for the next model mastermind to have the best intentions for their country? With dictatorships, you never know, while actively forgoing the freedom, rights, and higher probabilities of longer-termed economic success that come with open and free markets, free electoral systems, and a competitive market of ideas. Finally, it begs the question.

Read also

Mozambique’s main opposition leader goes on trial over post-election unrest

Ethiopia and Eritrea amass forces along border, heightening war fears, sources say

Free trade across Africa? Why policy must catch up with small-scale cross-border traders

Is it worth the bargain? 

Generally, Kagame and Rwanda-model sympathizers usually quote the results as the rationale for its adoption. But beyond that, a pertinent question to ask is, “is it truly worth the bargain?” Is it worth the risk of perpetual authoritarian governments and obscurely promised rewards of economic progress? Is it worth it to sell personal freedoms for economic progress via a political hegemony?

Other economic examples exist that have refused this bargain. And not in just Europe or amongst the Asian Tigers but here in Africa. Botswana defied the socialist trend in Africa in the 60s and was heavily criticized as not being pan-African. However, what has resulted has been measurable, consistent economic growth for six decades. Thanks to minimal government intervention in the economy, low income, corporate tax regimes, and a strong and separate judiciary that upholds individual and property rights even against bureaucratic power, Botswana’s GDP per capita has grown by 9% per year from 1966 onwards. This is an example African countries can model. One where the freedom to determine one’s political, economic, and social fate can be obtained alongside consistent economic progress.

In reality, Kagame’s so-called Rwandan ‘miracle’ bears little or no divinity. It is brutishly simplifying a national system down to a few basic functions and forcing them to work in a systematic manner that produces results. Nations like Russia and China, and many others from the old Imperial world have proven this governance approach works with the risk of advent implosion with the rise in prosperity as people begin to demand more freedoms, or even due to stagnancy in economic and societal status effected by the class systems these authoritarian governments enforce. Therefore, it is nothing new, nothing enticing, and nothing worthy of emulation. The 19th and 20th centuries were the battlegrounds of these ideas. Eventually, imperialist, and communist ideals ceded to free-market capitalism’s results. Dictators also lost favor to majority rule.


This article expresses the views and opinions of the author, and does not necessarily reflect the views of Qiraat Africa and its editors.

Source: Qiraat Africa
Tags: 1994 Rwandan genocidePaul KagameRwandaRwandan Economic Miracle
Chike D. Ibewuike

Chike D. Ibewuike

Writer, researcher and public policy enthusiast.

Related Posts

Hormuz block affected Africa in four places: what the continent must do to avoid future shocks
Central Africa

Hormuz block affected Africa in four places: what the continent must do to avoid future shocks

November 17, 2026
Rwanda
East Africa

Five EU countries starting talks with Rwanda on deportation hub, Austria says

November 16, 2026
AU grants $10.4m for Mpox emergency response
Central Africa

Africa CDC says Ebola outbreak still out of control six months since it was declared

November 16, 2026
DR Congo’s former leader, Kabila rejects accusations he harboured rebels
Central Africa

DR Congo: At least 44 dead in attack by ISIS-linked gunmen

November 15, 2026
Ethiopian coffee exports earn more than $500 million in just two months
East Africa

Ethiopia’s coffee exports fetch more than $870 million

November 11, 2026
Regional conflicts raise fears of renewed piracy in the Gulf of Aden
East Africa

Regional conflicts raise fears of renewed piracy in the Gulf of Aden

November 9, 2026

Search Qiraat Africa

No Result
View All Result

Follow on Twitter

Follow @africanqiraat

Trending

Africa’s 10 Strongest Currencies in June 2026

Africa’s 10 Strongest Currencies in June 2026

July 8, 2026
Kumbi Saleh, the capital of the ancient Ghana Empire

Kumbi Saleh, the capital of the ancient Ghana Empire

October 13, 2025
Tunka Manin (c. 1010–1078), the last ruler of the Ghana Empire

Tunka Manin (c. 1010–1078), the last ruler of the Ghana Empire

December 12, 2025
Equatorial Guinea

Equatorial Guinea orders crackdown on sex in government offices after videos leaked

November 6, 2024
Zaghawa people of northeastern Chad and western Sudan

Zaghawa people of northeastern Chad and western Sudan

March 3, 2026
The Bamiléké of western Cameroon

The Bamiléké of western Cameroon

September 18, 2024

Facebook

Sections

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Opinion
  • Infographics
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Figures
  • Culture & Literature
  • Follow Ups
  • Historical Readings
  • Interview
  • Studies


© Copyright Qiraat Africa. Developed by Bunnaj Media .

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Analysis & Report
  • Studies
  • Opinion
  • Interview
  • Culture & Literature
  • Figures
  • Historical Readings
  • Regions

© 2021 Copyright Qiraat Africa.