Qiraat Africa
عربي  |  Fr
Advertisement
  • News
    • All
    • Climate Change
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Energy
    • Health
    • Migration
    • Mining
    • Politics
    • Security
    • Society
    • Sport
    Somalia launches Centennial Vision 2060 roadmap for ‘peace, prospertity and progress’

    Somalia orders UAE ambassador to leave, citing ‘invasion’

    Nigeria’s president Tinubu says economy is recovering, calls for end to protests against hardship

    Nigeria’s Tinubu asks parliament to decriminalise attempted suicide

    South Africans vote as anger over failing services threatens ANC

    South Africa’s ANC and partners near coalition deal to sideline poll-topping DA in Johannesburg

    Mozambique: Opposition leader Mondlane announces break in election protests

    Mozambique’s main opposition leader goes on trial over post-election unrest

    Eritrea wary of ‘war-mongering’ Ethiopia

    Ethiopia and Eritrea amass forces along border, heightening war fears, sources say

    Nigeria’s state-owned NNPC records $4.2 billion after-tax profit in 2025

    Nigeria’s central bank, NNPC sign deal to support forex inflows, energy funding

    South Africa arrests four men suspected of planning to fight for Russia

    South Africa police searches for motive behind deadly shootings

    Guinea plans regional gold refining hub as West African race intensifies

    Guinea’s miners stockpile gold after refinery rules halted exports, sources say

    Nigerian lawmakers mediate rift with Africa’s richest man

    Dangote Refinery to expand IPO by up to 30% to $2.1 billion, sources say

  • Analysis
    • All
    • Climate Change
    • Digital & Tech
    • Economy
    • Energy & Power
    • Health
    • Politics
    • Security
    • Society
    Free trade across Africa? Why policy must catch up with small-scale cross-border traders

    Free trade across Africa? Why policy must catch up with small-scale cross-border traders

    Hormuz block affected Africa in four places: what the continent must do to avoid future shocks

    Hormuz block affected Africa in four places: what the continent must do to avoid future shocks

    What is standing in the way of science’s ability to eradicate malaria? 3 areas where action can have an influence

    What is standing in the way of science’s ability to eradicate malaria? 3 areas where action can have an influence

    African Union summit clouded by Saudi-UAE rivalry in Horn of Africa

    Opportunities and Challenges of the AU’s Education in Emergencies Initiative

    Abiy Ahmed Tested: How the Tigray Alliance Is Reshaping Ethiopia’s Security—And What Comes Next

    Abiy Ahmed Tested: How the Tigray Alliance Is Reshaping Ethiopia’s Security—And What Comes Next

    UN report says Africa’s share of global trade stands at 3 percent

    AfCFTA: The Trade Rules Poised to Weave Africa’s Fragmented Textile Markets into One

    The global panel on inequality needs African evidence: here’s how it could work

    The global panel on inequality needs African evidence: here’s how it could work

    Why Africa needs a new credit agency

    Why Africa needs a new credit agency

    Japan signs deal with Namibia to explore for rare earth minerals

    Africa’s mineral strength is wasted if countries don’t work together – new report

  • Studies
    China could drive Africa’s renewable energy revolution, report says

    A study shows wind and solar projects in Kenya and South Africa don’t always benefit the communities that host them

    Angola’s lengthy war shaped the way farmers utilised fire—why it matters

    Angola’s lengthy war shaped the way farmers utilised fire—why it matters

    Schooling is the most severely affected by conflict when children are the target – Study

    Schooling is the most severely affected by conflict when children are the target – Study

    Pensions for Botswana’s elderly are expanding, but care services are lacking—study follows 20 years

    Pensions for Botswana’s elderly are expanding, but care services are lacking—study follows 20 years

    60 new cosmic structures have been discovered by South Africa’s MeerKAT telescope, which is mapping previously unseen gaps between galaxies

    60 new cosmic structures have been discovered by South Africa’s MeerKAT telescope, which is mapping previously unseen gaps between galaxies

    Benin government says armed forces foil coup attempt

    Coup contagion? A rash of African power grabs suggests copycats are taking note of others’ success

    One in three South Africans have never heard of AI: what this means for policy

    One in three South Africans have never heard of AI: what this means for policy

    Social Media as a Catalyst for the Spread of Dangerous Wealth Ritual Myths

    Social Media as a Catalyst for the Spread of Dangerous Wealth Ritual Myths

    Overcoming Education Barriers for Young Mothers in Sub-Saharan Africa

    Overcoming Education Barriers for Young Mothers in Sub-Saharan Africa

  • Infographics
  • Figures
    South Sudan’s presidency announces postponement of long-delayed election by two years

    South Sudan vote: UN warns political transition must hold beyond polling day

    Usman Dan Fodio (1754-1817): Teacher, philosopher, and revolutionary reformer

    Usman Dan Fodio (1754-1817): Teacher, philosopher, and revolutionary reformer

    Sokhna Magat Diop (1917–2003): Senegalese cleric

    Sokhna Magat Diop (1917–2003): Senegalese cleric

    Ahmad Baba al-Timbukti (1556-1627): Writer and scholar

    Ahmad Baba al-Timbukti (1556-1627): Writer and scholar

    Namibia: Anger over Dubai COP28 trip by president Geingob’s children

    Hage Geingob (1941–2024): Former President of Namibia

    Cape Verde president says governments must discuss colonial reparations

    José Maria Neves: President of Cape Verde

    Jorge Bom Jesus: Linguist and former Prime Minister of São Tomé and Príncipe

    Jorge Bom Jesus: Linguist and former Prime Minister of São Tomé and Príncipe

    Joseph Leabua Jonathan (1914-1987): Former Prime Minister of Lesotho

    Joseph Leabua Jonathan (1914-1987): Former Prime Minister of Lesotho

    Gambia’s president Barrow faces backlash over ‘death wish’ on archrival

    Adama Barrow: President of the Republic of The Gambia

  • History
    Kwanza Corridor-Cultural Landscape, Angola

    Kwanza Corridor-Cultural Landscape, Angola

    Gasumo, the southernmost source of the Nile, Burundi

    Gasumo, the southernmost source of the Nile, Burundi

    Loango ancient slavery harbour, the Republic of the Congo

    Loango ancient slavery harbour, the Republic of the Congo

    Archaeological site of Tchitundu-Hulu, Angola

    Archaeological site of Tchitundu-Hulu, Angola

    Manovo-Gounda St. Floris National Park, Central African Republic

    Manovo-Gounda St. Floris National Park, Central African Republic

    Lake Malawi (Lake Nyasa) National Park, Malawi

    Lake Malawi (Lake Nyasa) National Park, Malawi

    Fasil Ghebbi, Gondar Region, Ethiopia

    Fasil Ghebbi, Gondar Region, Ethiopia

    Bwindi Impenetrable National Park, Uganda

    Bwindi Impenetrable National Park, Uganda

    Fort Jesus, Mombasa, Kenya

    Fort Jesus, Mombasa, Kenya

  • Others
    • Culture / Literature
    • Interview
    • Opinion
  • Countries
    • Country profiles
    • Regions
      • Central Africa
      • East Africa
      • Southern Africa
      • West Africa
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • All
    • Climate Change
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Energy
    • Health
    • Migration
    • Mining
    • Politics
    • Security
    • Society
    • Sport
    Somalia launches Centennial Vision 2060 roadmap for ‘peace, prospertity and progress’

    Somalia orders UAE ambassador to leave, citing ‘invasion’

    Nigeria’s president Tinubu says economy is recovering, calls for end to protests against hardship

    Nigeria’s Tinubu asks parliament to decriminalise attempted suicide

    South Africans vote as anger over failing services threatens ANC

    South Africa’s ANC and partners near coalition deal to sideline poll-topping DA in Johannesburg

    Mozambique: Opposition leader Mondlane announces break in election protests

    Mozambique’s main opposition leader goes on trial over post-election unrest

    Eritrea wary of ‘war-mongering’ Ethiopia

    Ethiopia and Eritrea amass forces along border, heightening war fears, sources say

    Nigeria’s state-owned NNPC records $4.2 billion after-tax profit in 2025

    Nigeria’s central bank, NNPC sign deal to support forex inflows, energy funding

    South Africa arrests four men suspected of planning to fight for Russia

    South Africa police searches for motive behind deadly shootings

    Guinea plans regional gold refining hub as West African race intensifies

    Guinea’s miners stockpile gold after refinery rules halted exports, sources say

    Nigerian lawmakers mediate rift with Africa’s richest man

    Dangote Refinery to expand IPO by up to 30% to $2.1 billion, sources say

  • Analysis
    • All
    • Climate Change
    • Digital & Tech
    • Economy
    • Energy & Power
    • Health
    • Politics
    • Security
    • Society
    Free trade across Africa? Why policy must catch up with small-scale cross-border traders

    Free trade across Africa? Why policy must catch up with small-scale cross-border traders

    Hormuz block affected Africa in four places: what the continent must do to avoid future shocks

    Hormuz block affected Africa in four places: what the continent must do to avoid future shocks

    What is standing in the way of science’s ability to eradicate malaria? 3 areas where action can have an influence

    What is standing in the way of science’s ability to eradicate malaria? 3 areas where action can have an influence

    African Union summit clouded by Saudi-UAE rivalry in Horn of Africa

    Opportunities and Challenges of the AU’s Education in Emergencies Initiative

    Abiy Ahmed Tested: How the Tigray Alliance Is Reshaping Ethiopia’s Security—And What Comes Next

    Abiy Ahmed Tested: How the Tigray Alliance Is Reshaping Ethiopia’s Security—And What Comes Next

    UN report says Africa’s share of global trade stands at 3 percent

    AfCFTA: The Trade Rules Poised to Weave Africa’s Fragmented Textile Markets into One

    The global panel on inequality needs African evidence: here’s how it could work

    The global panel on inequality needs African evidence: here’s how it could work

    Why Africa needs a new credit agency

    Why Africa needs a new credit agency

    Japan signs deal with Namibia to explore for rare earth minerals

    Africa’s mineral strength is wasted if countries don’t work together – new report

  • Studies
    China could drive Africa’s renewable energy revolution, report says

    A study shows wind and solar projects in Kenya and South Africa don’t always benefit the communities that host them

    Angola’s lengthy war shaped the way farmers utilised fire—why it matters

    Angola’s lengthy war shaped the way farmers utilised fire—why it matters

    Schooling is the most severely affected by conflict when children are the target – Study

    Schooling is the most severely affected by conflict when children are the target – Study

    Pensions for Botswana’s elderly are expanding, but care services are lacking—study follows 20 years

    Pensions for Botswana’s elderly are expanding, but care services are lacking—study follows 20 years

    60 new cosmic structures have been discovered by South Africa’s MeerKAT telescope, which is mapping previously unseen gaps between galaxies

    60 new cosmic structures have been discovered by South Africa’s MeerKAT telescope, which is mapping previously unseen gaps between galaxies

    Benin government says armed forces foil coup attempt

    Coup contagion? A rash of African power grabs suggests copycats are taking note of others’ success

    One in three South Africans have never heard of AI: what this means for policy

    One in three South Africans have never heard of AI: what this means for policy

    Social Media as a Catalyst for the Spread of Dangerous Wealth Ritual Myths

    Social Media as a Catalyst for the Spread of Dangerous Wealth Ritual Myths

    Overcoming Education Barriers for Young Mothers in Sub-Saharan Africa

    Overcoming Education Barriers for Young Mothers in Sub-Saharan Africa

  • Infographics
  • Figures
    South Sudan’s presidency announces postponement of long-delayed election by two years

    South Sudan vote: UN warns political transition must hold beyond polling day

    Usman Dan Fodio (1754-1817): Teacher, philosopher, and revolutionary reformer

    Usman Dan Fodio (1754-1817): Teacher, philosopher, and revolutionary reformer

    Sokhna Magat Diop (1917–2003): Senegalese cleric

    Sokhna Magat Diop (1917–2003): Senegalese cleric

    Ahmad Baba al-Timbukti (1556-1627): Writer and scholar

    Ahmad Baba al-Timbukti (1556-1627): Writer and scholar

    Namibia: Anger over Dubai COP28 trip by president Geingob’s children

    Hage Geingob (1941–2024): Former President of Namibia

    Cape Verde president says governments must discuss colonial reparations

    José Maria Neves: President of Cape Verde

    Jorge Bom Jesus: Linguist and former Prime Minister of São Tomé and Príncipe

    Jorge Bom Jesus: Linguist and former Prime Minister of São Tomé and Príncipe

    Joseph Leabua Jonathan (1914-1987): Former Prime Minister of Lesotho

    Joseph Leabua Jonathan (1914-1987): Former Prime Minister of Lesotho

    Gambia’s president Barrow faces backlash over ‘death wish’ on archrival

    Adama Barrow: President of the Republic of The Gambia

  • History
    Kwanza Corridor-Cultural Landscape, Angola

    Kwanza Corridor-Cultural Landscape, Angola

    Gasumo, the southernmost source of the Nile, Burundi

    Gasumo, the southernmost source of the Nile, Burundi

    Loango ancient slavery harbour, the Republic of the Congo

    Loango ancient slavery harbour, the Republic of the Congo

    Archaeological site of Tchitundu-Hulu, Angola

    Archaeological site of Tchitundu-Hulu, Angola

    Manovo-Gounda St. Floris National Park, Central African Republic

    Manovo-Gounda St. Floris National Park, Central African Republic

    Lake Malawi (Lake Nyasa) National Park, Malawi

    Lake Malawi (Lake Nyasa) National Park, Malawi

    Fasil Ghebbi, Gondar Region, Ethiopia

    Fasil Ghebbi, Gondar Region, Ethiopia

    Bwindi Impenetrable National Park, Uganda

    Bwindi Impenetrable National Park, Uganda

    Fort Jesus, Mombasa, Kenya

    Fort Jesus, Mombasa, Kenya

  • Others
    • Culture / Literature
    • Interview
    • Opinion
  • Countries
    • Country profiles
    • Regions
      • Central Africa
      • East Africa
      • Southern Africa
      • West Africa
No Result
View All Result
Qiraat Africa
عربي  |  Fr
No Result
View All Result
Home Regions East Africa

A study shows wind and solar projects in Kenya and South Africa don’t always benefit the communities that host them

August 9, 2026
China could drive Africa’s renewable energy revolution, report says

FILE PHOTO: Wind turbines produce renewable energy outside Caledon, South Africa, May 20, 2020. Picture taken May 20, 2020. REUTERS/Mike Hutchings/File Photo

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By Lars Buur*

 

Private investment in clean energy projects is growing: in sub-Saharan Africa, it’s approaching US$40 billion a year. These “green transition” investments in solar and wind power are meant to benefit the environment and develop the communities where they are based.

I am a specialist in natural resource governance and in a recent paper I looked at whether local communities in South Africa and Kenya benefited from these investments.

Postdoctoral fellow Jacob Ulrich, research assistant Eivind Bjørås and I wanted to find out how green energy projects in Kenya and South Africa affected local communities: who benefited, who decided how benefits were shared, and who missed out.

Read also

Somalia orders UAE ambassador to leave, citing ‘invasion’

Nigeria’s Tinubu asks parliament to decriminalise attempted suicide

South Africa’s ANC and partners near coalition deal to sideline poll-topping DA in Johannesburg

We found two broad approaches. The first was “buying in”, where communities become partners in projects through co-ownership, long-term land leases or benefit-sharing agreements. The second was “buying out”, where communities are compensated with money for giving up or losing their land to the project or are relocated, and are excluded from the project’s longer-term benefits.

In South Africa, we researched the Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer Procurement Programme. This is a government programme that invites private companies to bid to build wind and solar power projects and then sell the electricity they generate to the national grid. The private companies have to give local communities at least 2.5% ownership.

Recharge your morning. Receive daily insights about Africa from the people who actually know the continent.

But our research found that even this well designed approach can end up buying communities out, if communities have no say in what a fair deal looks like. Our research found that South Africa’s big green energy projects, mainly in the Northern Cape, hardly benefited local communities.

In Kenya, we interviewed local community members, officials and developers who’d been affected by the Lake Turkana Wind Power project, Africa’s largest wind farm.

The project was built on land traditionally used by pastoralist communities. Protests and lawsuits followed, resulting in long-running conflicts between investors and local communities.

We concluded that both cases point to the same problem. Green energy projects often measure success through jobs, dividends and infrastructure, but overlook what communities value most: their land, livelihoods and way of life. For pastoralist communities, money cannot replace access to the land they need to move livestock and sustain their way of life.

Until investors start asking what communities value, and build it in from the start, Africa’s green transition will keep buying people out instead of buying them in.

South Africa’s renewable energy programme

South Africa’s renewable energy programme is designed as a model of buying-in. It was created with social justice in mind, where companies have to tender for projects that are awarded by the state. The companies bidding for contracts must commit to a certain level of job creation, local (Black) ownership and community development.

However, in practice, the picture is more complicated. Our research found that private energy companies in South Africa aim to meet their community obligations because it is a condition of being awarded a tender to set up a project. This is different to wanting communities to have a real say in the kind of development they need.

In these projects, when money does flow to the communities it often takes years. Sometimes the communities only earn dividends years after construction starts once the project is up and running. In areas of deep poverty, such delays can be devastating to a community that gave up land for a solar farm, for example.

The compensation people receive is also part of the problem. We found that people near renewable energy projects in South Africa often lose their land and are not compensated with money or other land but with community halls and social services that are chosen by the private energy companies.

These only meet some needs, and the communities have no say, even though consultation is built into the tender process. Private energy companies need to work with local communities to decide how they want to be included, or whether direct cash transfers, or some combination of cash and services, would better reflect what communities themselves value.

Kenya’s Lake Turkana Wind Power project

The Lake Turkana Wind Power project in Kenya tells a different yet similar story.

When it was launched, the project looked promising. It came with backing from several Scandinavian state-backed investment funds. These investors were expected to meet global standards for how they treated people and the environment.

But the local Rendille, Samburu and Turkana El Molo communities experienced things differently. For them, fair compensation meant secure ways to earn a living, access to land and water, and recognition of their customary rights to land that their survival depended upon.

Communities pushed back, setting up roadblocks on the roads the project had built. Investors tried to adjust their approach, setting up a foundation to compensate affected people.

While one village was relocated, many more pastoralist communities lost access to land they relied on for grazing, water and cultural practices. This was because the compensation scheme didn’t recognise nomadic groups without permanent settlements as affected people, and they were excluded.

For people whose way of life depended on moving across the land, this was not a fair deal.

Eventually, local residents on behalf of the Indigenous pastoralist communities took their case to the Kenyan courts, which ruled in favour of their land and customary rights.

However, the Kenyan court ruling had little practical effect, because although the court agreed that the communities’ land had been taken in an irregular manner, it did not stop the wind farm from going ahead.

This is an example of a project following international standards for community consultation, resettlement and compensation, where nevertheless, the affected communities were bought out rather than bought in.

What needs to be done

For local communities, a fair deal means being able to keep making a living, having access to energy, protecting their rights to land and water, and having a real say in decisions that affect their future.

The gap between what investors value and what communities value needs to be closed. That starts with recognising that different communities want different things. For some, financial compensation may be enough. But many want a lasting stake in the project that delivers benefits over many years. Communities also want a voice in decisions about how green energy projects affect their lives.

If green energy investments are to deliver on their promise of development, governments and investors need to start by asking communities what they consider a fair deal. Land, livelihoods, culture and ways of life may be just as important as financial returns.

These priorities should shape projects from the beginning, rather than being treated as something to deal with after decisions have already been made.

ـــــــــــــــــــــــ

* Professor in Political Economy of Development and interim Head of Department, Roskilde Universityز

Source: The Conversation
Tags: KenyaSolar projectsSouth AfricaWind projects

Related Posts

Mozambique: Opposition leader Mondlane announces break in election protests
East Africa

Mozambique’s main opposition leader goes on trial over post-election unrest

November 18, 2026
Eritrea wary of ‘war-mongering’ Ethiopia
East Africa

Ethiopia and Eritrea amass forces along border, heightening war fears, sources say

November 18, 2026
Nigeria’s state-owned NNPC records $4.2 billion after-tax profit in 2025
Economy

Nigeria’s central bank, NNPC sign deal to support forex inflows, energy funding

November 18, 2026
Free trade across Africa? Why policy must catch up with small-scale cross-border traders
African Union

Free trade across Africa? Why policy must catch up with small-scale cross-border traders

November 17, 2026
Hormuz block affected Africa in four places: what the continent must do to avoid future shocks
Central Africa

Hormuz block affected Africa in four places: what the continent must do to avoid future shocks

November 17, 2026
South Africa arrests four men suspected of planning to fight for Russia
Featured

South Africa police searches for motive behind deadly shootings

November 17, 2026

Search Qiraat Africa

No Result
View All Result

Follow on Twitter

Follow @africanqiraat

Trending

Africa’s 10 Strongest Currencies in June 2026

Africa’s 10 Strongest Currencies in June 2026

July 8, 2026
Kumbi Saleh, the capital of the ancient Ghana Empire

Kumbi Saleh, the capital of the ancient Ghana Empire

October 13, 2025
DR Congo’s President Tshisekedi calls for sanctions against Rwanda

DR Congo president orders probe into copper and cobalt export revenues, document shows

April 28, 2026
The Bamiléké of western Cameroon

The Bamiléké of western Cameroon

September 18, 2024
Zaghawa people of northeastern Chad and western Sudan

Zaghawa people of northeastern Chad and western Sudan

March 3, 2026
Tunka Manin (c. 1010–1078), the last ruler of the Ghana Empire

Tunka Manin (c. 1010–1078), the last ruler of the Ghana Empire

December 12, 2025

Facebook

Sections

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Opinion
  • Infographics
  • News
  • Analysis
  • Figures
  • Culture & Literature
  • Follow Ups
  • Historical Readings
  • Interview
  • Studies


© Copyright Qiraat Africa. Developed by Bunnaj Media .

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Analysis & Report
  • Studies
  • Opinion
  • Interview
  • Culture & Literature
  • Figures
  • Historical Readings
  • Regions

© 2021 Copyright Qiraat Africa.